Skip to main content

How to Think About Qur'an and Revelation from the Perspective of Progressive Muslim Thought -A Brief Preliminary Reflection

 CAVEAT -This preliminary reflection is written for non academic audiences and is not meant to be a fully systematic ,academic treatment on the subject but primarily as a piece that I can share on social media. I hope to develop these ideas more fully in the future.

To understand the nature of progressive Muslim thought it is essential to understand how it approaches the nature of the Qur’an and the nature of the idea of Revelation itself. In my previous writings on progressive Islam ( here and here,) drawing upon the work of A. Al-Khuli and Nasr Abu Zayd, I emphasised the idea that progressive Islam considers the Qur’an as a socio-culturally produced and literary discourse or set of discourses (for summary of parts of this work click here). In other words, according to progressive Muslim thought there is an organic and symbiotic link between the specific religious environment out of which the Qur’an emerged and the nature of the Qur’an itself.


Importantly, from the perspective of philosophy of religion that is embraced by progressive Muslim thought, namely one informed by process-relational metaphysics, the concept of “Revelation” (i.e. what constitutes sources of Divine signs) is not text-dependent but emphasises the validity of the concept of “Revelation” by pointing to the idea of: 

1.centrality of human religious experience, including the mystical and perennialist , as a universal phenomenon historically and across diverse cultures and civilisations 

2.  the natural world and human rational faculty as sources of Divine signs. These Divine signs are repeatedly used in the Qur’an as such. In this respect, there is a qualitative difference here between progressive Islam’s approach to Revelation (and the nature Qur’an) and Islamic orthodoxy. For Islamic orthodoxy it is the plain, ahistorical and non-philosophically informed reading of Qur’an itself (and the associated orthodox canonical literature) that sets the parameters of what constitutes Divine signs (including crucially the Qur’an itself) whereas in progressive Muslim thought, the concept of “Revelation” is a by-product of a particular approach to philosophy of religion understood from the perspective of process-relational theology through which Qur’anic theological ideas are conceptualised and interpreted. This difference between the two approaches exists in part, because in progressive Muslim thought the understanding of the emergence and nature of the Qur’an are metaphysically different from that of the Islamic orthodoxy which brings me to another point.  

 

Since the publication of my 2017 book on progressive Islam important studies have been penned by progressive minded Muslim scholars further emphasising the historicity of the Qur’an and the contingent and evolving nature of  human religious experience including that termed “Prophetic” religious experience. Moreover, additional important   research has been produced closely linking the emergence and the nature of the Qur’an to the religious ecosystem of late Antiquity Near-East. This research ,among others, highlights the inter-textual nature of the origins and the composition of the Qur’an. Hence, in concert with process-relational metaphysics/theology and in contrast with orthodox Islamic dogma, progressive Islam’s approach to scripture as source of Divine signs is premised on the metaphysical impossibility of a purely Divine text and the metaphysical impossibility of the non-contingent and non-evolving nature of human religious experience itself including the “Prophetic”.  


Importantly, this approach does not necessarily imply that the Qur’an (or more generally the rich Islamic theological, philosophical, and spiritual mysticism-based literature) is bereft of any sound theological ideas  but that these ideas expressed in the Qur’an ought to be interpreted: 

1. in the light of the metaphysical parameters of process-relational metaphysics in general and process-relation theology specifically both of which reject the concept of God as conceptualised in classical theism (including the Islamic version of it). 

2.in the light of its intertextuality and the historical context in which the Qur’an originated.


As noted above these are ideas that I am still developing and hope to provide more substantial reflections in the future . 

 

 

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

ON HIJAB AND AWRAH OF WOMEN AND SLAVES ( from FROM EL FADL’S ‘speaking in God’s name p.481-484)

ON HIJAB AND AWRAH OF WOMEN AND SLAVES ( FROM EL FADL’S ‘speaking in God’s name p.481-484)-reproduced verbatim There are several material elements that are often ignored when discussing the issue of ḥijāb or the ‘awrah of women. These elements suggest that the issue of fitnah might have dominated and shaped the discourse on the ‘awrah of women, but they are also informative as to the possible authorial enterprise behind the fitnah traditions. There are six main elements that, I believe, warrant careful examination in trying to analyze the laws of ‘awrah, and that invite us to re-examine the relationship between ‘awrah and fitnah. Firstly, early jurists disagreed on the meaning of zīnah (adornments) that women are commanded to cover. Some jurists argued that it is all of the body including the hair and face except for one eye. The majority argued that women must cover their full body except for the face and hands. Some jurists held that women may expose their feet and their arms up ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Khaled Abou El Fadl's Approach to the Hadith

Khaled Abou El Fadl's   Approach to the Hadith Khaled Abou El Fadl (b.1963) is one of the most distinguished scholars of Islamic law today. He is also one of the few progressive Muslim scholars who has fully engaged with the postmodern episteme, post-enlightenment hermeneutics, and literary theory, as well as applied them in relation to gen­der issues in Islam, including the interpretation of hadith pertaining to gender. Much of his Qur’anic hermeneutics and approach to Islamic jurisprudence is in agreement with scholars such as mohsen Kadivar and nasr Abu Zayd , and need not be repeated. However, El Fadl’s work also includes discussions pertaining to (in)determinacy of meaning, ambiguity of textual hermeneu­tics, and the process of meaning derivation as employed, for example, in literary theory and semiotics (which he has applied to both Qur’an and hadith texts) (El Fadl, 2001, 88). El Fadl has systematically engaged in these discussions and has applied them to the issue ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Expert Witness Report on Gender Interactions and Women Clothing in the Islamic Tradition

    Expert Witness Report on Gender Interactions and Women Clothing in the Islamic Tradition    Adis Duderija    The injunctions pertaining to women clothing in the Islamic interpretive tradition and gender relations in general (primarily Islamic jurisprudence known as fiqh) are result of interpretive processes that have taken several centuries to form. What is today considered four mainstream Sunni Islamic schools of law only reached large degree of hermeneutical stability   after over 400 years of juristic and legal methodology reasoning (Hallaq 2004 ; Jackson 2002). Jackson, who uses   a Darwinian metaphor of the survival of the fittest, describes   this process of the formation of mainstream Sunnism   as follows   by the end of the 4th/10th century, the madhhab had emerged as the exclusive repository of legal authority. From this point on, all interpretive activity, if it was to be sanctioned and recognized as aut...
Post a Comment
Read more